Showing posts with label Jody O'Guinn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jody O'Guinn. Show all posts

Monday, June 29, 2015

Residency Requirements

In a letter to her email list, Jane Adams pointed out a change to residency requirements on the agenda for tomorrow night's city council meeting. Currently, executive city employees are required to live within the city limits, all other city employees must live within 9 miles of the city, Under the current ordinance, this means that only 10 out of all the city employees are required to live in Carbondale. From the proposed ordinace: 

Pay Grade 9 City Attorney, Public Works Director, Finance Director, Police Chief, Fire Chief,
Administrative Services Director (Human Resources), Development Services
Director (Building, Planning/Zoning, Code Enforcement)


Pay Grade 8 Accounting Manager, Maintenance & Environmental Services Manager (PW),
Information Systems Manager (IT), Water Operations Manager


Pay Grade 8 Exemptions
Deputy Police Chief (2), Police Lieutenant (4), Assistant Fire Chief (3)


The City Manager position (unclassified pay grade) and the City Clerk (pay grade 6) are also
required to reside within the City limits according to City Code.


The city has not had a Police Chief since last summer, after the firing of then Chief Jody O'Guinn. Jeff Grubbs has filled the position as Interim Police Chief since then and both Mayor Mike Henry and City Manager Kevin Baity have expresses satisfaction with his work and a desire to hire him as Police Chief. However, Grubbs lives outside the city, but within the 9 miles required. For Grubbs to accept the position, he would need to sell or otherwise dispose of his current residence and move within city limits.

Furthermore, Fire Chief John Michalesko plans to retire in the near future, meaning that the city will either need to promote from within or recruit a new chief from outside. Apparently, the requirement to live within city limits is seen as a impediment in either case.

It would appear then, that while the city works to bring in outside businesses, students and new residents, city staff do not see it as a particularly desirable location to live and that requiring higher pay grade officials to live here is an impediment to recruiting them.

Below are the four options city staff has presented and the staff recommendation. You will note that leaving things as they are is not one of the four optioned presented:

A number of options were reviewed that include:
1. Require all new employees to live within the City limits. This is not an option as the police and fire
unions’ contract allow for residency within the 9-mile boundary. This matter was the subject of a legalcase in which the unions wanted to extend the boundary to greater than 9 miles. The result was a rulingin favor of the City to retain the 9-mile boundary.


2. Create more exemptions for more classes of executive employees, similar to the 1999 and 2005 Councilactions. This only serves to further alienate the few remaining employees who are bound by the Citylimits requirement. This could also lead to a discrimination law suit brought by those remaining nonexempted employees.


3. Eliminate the City limits requirement for executive employees. In other words, all employees have thesame rights and must live within the 9-mile boundary. The argument against this is “there will be a largenumber of employees leave the City limits.” As indicated above, currently only 10 employees (3.7%) arebound by this requirement therefore there cannot be a large number of employees leave the City.


4. Eliminate all residency requirements. Due to the previous legal decision in favor of the City and the 9-mile residency boundary, this is not a viable option. Each time the police and fire union contracts are upfor renegotiation, they try to argue extending the boundary; this year the argument was from 9 miles to20 miles.


RECOMMENDATION:
After conducting a review of the history presented above and the significantly small number of employees affected by the current City limit residency requirement, it is recommended the City Council choose Option 3above and adopt an Ordinance eliminating the City limits requirement for executive employees in pay grades 8 and 9, the City Manager and the City Clerk.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

No Police Chief

Following up on the multiple choice from yesterday, nearly a year has passed since City Manager Baity fired Police Chief Jody O'Guinn for unspecified reasons. As far as I  know, the city has made no attempt to search for a replacement or even post the opening, leaving Interim Chief Jeff Grubbs in place. Since Grubbs lives outside the city limits, assuming the position officially would require a move by him to Carbondale proper.

From statements he made during the mayoral election, Mayor Mike Henry favors keeping Grubbs on as chief. I would bet sometime before the end of the year, there is a low keyed search for a replacement chief, Grubbs moves his official residence within the city limits and gets the job.

Thursday, October 9, 2014

City Council Meeting

City Council has a special meeting scheduled for tonight, opening with citizen comments, then moving into closed session for a discussion regarding employees.  I would bet they will be discussing the termination of Chief Jody O'Guinn and hiring his replacement. I have heard third hand that council wants to bring in another outsider to head up the department in order to bring fresh eyes  and "shake things up".

I would much rather see acting chief Jeff Grubbs offered the position. The last outsider, O'Guinn, apparently didn't work out that well and we could expect someone unfamiliar with Carbondale to take at least a year to get familiar with the operation of the department as well as Carbondale itself.

Thursday, August 21, 2014

More on Chief O'Guinn's Firing

The Carbondale Times has a long look at the current situation surrounding the firing of Jody O'Guinn, while the Southern looks at the situation from O'Guinn's viewpoint. Meanwhile, Interim chief Jeff Grubbs, who held the position once before 2008-2009 says the department will take things one step at a time.

I did speak briefly with Grubbs Tuesday evening and he repeated that the department will take things slowly in the wake of O'Guinn's firing. When I asked him if he planed to seek the position permanently, he smiled and said it was way too early to even think about such a thing.

Here's an audio interview by Monica Zukas with the  parents of Molly Young and Pravin Varughese after the announcement of O'Guinn's firing. In case you don't want to sit through it, both families are quite happy O'Guinn is gone but feel the police department needs further investigation.

Monday, August 18, 2014

Chief O'Guinn Dismissed

Just got this email from the city manager's office.  Wow!

Effective Monday, August 18 at 9:00 a.m., I am dismissing Jody O'Guinn as Chief of Police for the City of Carbondale. Chief O'Guinn has served the City since June 2009. As of now, no timeline has been established for finding his successor.”

"I am naming Deputy Chief Jeff Grubbs to serve as Interim Police Chief. I have full faith and confidence in Deputy Chief Grubbs' ability to lead the Carbondale Police Department,” Baity states. “I want to stress that my decision to dismiss Chief O'Guinn is a confidential matter and has nothing to do with the unsolved cases or recent litigation filed against the City and the Chief. Any assumptions/allegations to this effect are completely unfounded."

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Arbor District Crime Meeting

There's a meeting at St. Francis Xavier Church at 7 p.m. tonight in the lower level of Xavier Hall to discuss recent crime in the area.  Though Chief Jody O'Guinn (who will be present, along with city manager Kevin Baity) says the city has not seen an increase in crime over last year, residents of the Arbor District are concerned because of several burglaries that have taken place in the area in the past couple of months.

The Crime Report map for Carbondale doesn't appear to show an outsized number of burglaries and thefts for the Arbor District, though.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Police Department FOIA Officer

Apparently the city/police department is getting quite a bit of heat over the recent shooting with the gun stolen from Chief O'Guinn as it has appointed a representative to handle FOIA requests directed to the police department:

In the interests of streamlining the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) process and expediting the requests for information, City Manager Allen Gill has appointed Assistant City Attorney Lenoard “Jamie” Snyder as FOIA Officer for the Police Department.  All future requests for Police Department reports and records are to be directed to Mr. Snyder’s office. As City Prosecutor, Mr. Snyder is very familiar with Police Department record keeping procedures and the critical nature of confidentiality in ongoing criminal investigations. As an attorney, he is also very familiar with FOIA requirements and exemptions. This shift of responsibilities will also help ease the growing workload on the Clerk’s office, so that other FOIA requests can be processed in a timely manner. The City Clerk will continue to be the FOIA Officer for all other requests.

Based on analysis of recent experience with providing adequate response to FOIA requests, City Manager Allen Gill has identified an area where service can be improved.  Most of the perceived delays and lack of response come in regard to requests for Police Department records and reports.  The Open Records Act provides numerous exemptions for police-related documents. Each of these exemptions for police-related records provides specific procedures and requirements for meeting the exemption.  On numerous occasions there have been differences of interpretation between the City Clerk’s office and the Police Department. When these differences come to the City Manager’s attention, Mr. Gill asks the City Attorney to rule on the request and each department is expected to abide by the City Attorney’s ruling.  The City Attorney’s opinion of these rulings must be final, as he is the one who must defend the City if the City is accused of violating FOIA regulations. This is the procedure agreed upon after the new FOIA rules were announced a year ago. Since that time, there has been a dramatic increase in FOIA requests, and this has also contributed to some of the delays.

State law allows for organizations to have more than one FOIA officer. The City had elected until now to have one FOIA officer for the entire organization, so as to centralize record keeping.  Increasing workloads and increasing complexity of requests have caused the City Manager  to reconsider this option. This recommendation has been discussed with Mayor Fritzler and he is in agreement with this proposed change.