Showing posts with label Debbie Moore. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Debbie Moore. Show all posts

Friday, May 4, 2012

Bye Bye Debbie

It appears the CCTB board met the night after the city ended its contract with the CCTB and fired executive director Debbie Moore. Looks like an olive branch extended towards the city.  However, I have to wonder if, given the support of the CCTB by tax revenues, if meetings such as this are in violation of Illinois' Open Meetings Act, which requires public notice of meetings by any organization supported by tax monies.  Organizations covered by the act include:

 all legislative, executive, administrative or advisory bodies of the
state, counties, townships, cities, villages, incorporated towns, school districts and all other
municipal corporations, boards, bureaus, committees or commissions of this State, and any
subsidiary bodies of any of the foregoing including but not limited to committees and
subcommittees which are supported in whole or in part by tax revenue, or which expend tax
revenue, except the General Assembly and committees or commissions thereof


As has been noted before, most of the funding for the CCTB comes from Carbondale's motel tax, which certainly seems to cover the CCTB and by extension, its governing board.

According to the Southern's story, Councilman Chris Wissmann, a voting member of the board, was not notified of the meeting, which also appears a violation of the Act.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Bye Bye CCTB

City council voted 6-1 last night, with Councilwoman McDaniel the lone opponent, to not renew its contract with the Carbondale Convention and Tourism Bureau, effectively defunding the organization, as the $275,000 provided by the city though its hotel/motel tax was far and away the CCTB's largest source of financial support.

Up in the air is what happens to the CCTB's facilities and website.  Councilwoman Jane Adams said she would like the city to take over maintenance of the website but Moore argued that the state owns it:

Councilwoman Jane Adams said she wanted to see the city retain ownership of the bureau’s website. Moore dismissed that notion after the vote, saying the state funds the portal.
“I will dismantle and destroy that website before I give it to anybody,” Moore said.

Interesting phrasing Moore uses there, given that in the sentence before, she states the state owns the website.  I guess you can't serve as executive director of something for some 20 years without developing a feeling of ownership.  Still, it was only after the city council starting putting pressure on the CCTB and Moore about how funds were spent that the Bureau's website got any attention and it still looks a work in progress.

Update:  From what I have heard, there had been active request from constituents to council members about defunding the CCTB and outsourcing tourism activities, causing them, with the exception of McDaniel, to readily approve the cancellation of the contract.

Update:  Apparently not gone yet, according to the Southern.

Tuesday, May 1, 2012

CCTB Coverage.

As I noted yesterday, the city council votes to enter into a contract with the Carbondale Convention and Tourism Bureau for this year's funding of the Bureau.  Here's an article from the DE on the subject and the Carbondale Times ran this.  Meanwhile, this is the most recent article run on the topic by the Southern Illinoisan.  The Southern's coverage is much more favorable toward the board and the CCTB in general than were the articles in the DE and CT.

From the Southern, this is the first comment I have read from anyone on the CCTB board regarding the expansion of the number of members on the board:

Moore and CCTB Board of Directors President Trace Brown said they added to the board because at least 15 seats had to be filled by the end of March, according to CCTB’s bylaws. The move was not made to stack the board against Fritzler’s appointments, they said.
“I don’t think we were doing anything to go in the backdoor on city council members,” Brown said.

 Moore said CCTB directors chose to expand the board to make reaching a quorum easier. She also said the board has had as many as 36 members during her two decades with the agency.

I'm not quite sure how expanding the number of  people on the board will make getting to a quorum easier, since now at least 15 people have to show up to conduct business whereas before it was only 8, but maybe the board is privy to some math or attendance numbers of which I am not aware.

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Carbondale Convention and Tourism Bureau

The Carbondale Times has done a fine job these past weeks covering the embattled Convention and Tourism Bureau. See here and here, almost all of which has been ignored by the Southern Illinoisan.  Unfortunately, the site runs about a week late posting stories so this week's article on the vote expanding the number of seats on the CCTB board doesn't appear on the site.  According to the article, at last Monday's meeting, the board voted to almost double in size the number of members appointed by the CCTB to it.

 According to this, the size of the board was 16 members.  According to the Times article, in recent years it totaled 15.  Now it apparently totals 23, with all of the past members, who were appointed by Mayor Brad Cole, elected to the newly created seats, with the exception of Councilman Chris Wissmann.  According to the Times article, Mayor Fritzler had planned to replace all of the city appointed board members with new people.  At last count, I heard Mayor Fritzler has 10 people applying for the 8 spots available. 

Rather a foolish move on the board's part. While it helps preserve Executive Director Debbie Moore's position at the Bureau, since it would take a majority vote of the board to remover her and the members appointed to the new seats all appeared in support of her performance at council meetings, it gives more impetus to calls for an audit, which councilwoman Jane Adams has pushed for already.  It will likely also result in more money cut from the funds provided by the city to the CCTB, which accounts for about 80% of the CCTB's financial support already.

Monday, February 20, 2012

More on CCTB Budget

If you missed it, the Carbondale Times has a breakdown of where the money goes for the Carbondale Convention and Tourism Bureau.  The CCTB's total budget runs a hair over $405,000 with most of that ($317,500) coming from the C'dale hotel/motel tax. The rest comes from the county, state and various grants. 

47% of that goes for salaries. Another 30% goes for insurance, administration, rent and technical support (which I assume includes the CCTB website). That leaves about 23% of the budget for promotional activities and special projects.  Since from what I see from the CCTB's strategic plan, most of its focus is on promoting Carbondale and the region, I would think a greater percentage of the budget would focus on those activities.

Mayor Fritzler's proposal to pull $120,000 from the CCTB budget would reduce the CCTB budget by 30%. According to CCTB executive director Debbie Moore, if this cut takes place, the Bureau would have to eliminate the following:

 --match a $37,500 U.S. Department of Agriculture grant to support the use of locally grown specialty crops.

-- a proposal to the  Illinois Office of Tourism for a tourism attraction development grant.

--cultural heritage partnership project  for a proposed single-day heritage festival in the city. Among event sites listed were the Varsity Center for the Arts and the Fuller Dome Home.

--community youth golf team and expanded efforts to bring Amateur Athletic Union tournaments to the park district's Hickory Ridge Public Golf Center.

--CCTB's  development of arts-centered marketing designed to bring cultural tourists to the city.

--New visitor guides

--Community contributions to Lights Fantastic Parade, July 4 fireworks display, and CMS Friday Night Fair

From what I see, if the proposed $120,000 cut goes through, the CCTB would, at least according to Executive Director Moore, cut almost all of its promotional activities, which is the primary reason for the organization's existance in the first place and rely on the Bureau's website for outreach and promotion.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

City Council Meeting

Sat in on part of the city council meeting last night.  Missed the vote on the chicken ordinance but it passed, though with a limit of 20 licensed coops in the city at any one time.  Some of the details from the ordinance:
oops and enclosures must be covered in mesh, and they must be kept dry, clean, odor-free and in a sanitary manner.

- The odor of chicken waste must be contained to the property of the chicken owner. No more than three cubic feet of chicken waste may be stored on property at any one time. Composting of chicken waste is encouraged.
- Coops may not be located in side or front yards, and they must be at least 15 feet from the property line and 25 feet from neighboring residences.
- Coops must have at least 4 square feet of floor space but no more than 40 square feet. They must be at least 5 feet tall, but cannot be taller than 8 feet.

No indication who will handle inspection of the coops.

Discussion of funding of assorted community organizations took up the couple of hours of the meeting, with the main focus on Mayor Fritzler's proposal to pull $120,000 in funding from the Carbondale Convention and Tourism Bureau's and distribute it among other organizations, several of which had apparently been asked in January to present proposals for what they would do with additional funding.  Apprently, cutting the hotel/motel tax was not given consideration.

Councilwoman Jane Adams had a number of questions for Bureau Director Debbie Moore, most of which, of those I caught, concerned the Bureau's website. Adams appeared especially concerned that Moore devoted more time to her personal website than she did to the CCTVB's site and that Moore's website ranked higher in Google rankings than did the Bureau's.  Moore responded that the Bureau's website was under construction and appeared to take offense at Adams' questions regarding her personal website.  It does appear that the current version of the  Bureau's website is fairly recent, as the event calendar shows no events in the area prior to this month and several of the pages (favorite food events, camping, favorite grocery shops) are blank.

Mayor Fritzler cut off Adams' questioning before she had finished, appearing to want to give other council members time to ask questions of the CCTVB.  However, Councilpeople McDaniels, Monty, and Jack, preferred to make comments about the proposed shift in funding from the CCTVB.  All three were opposed, or at least concerned that not enough time had been devoted to the proposal.  Still seems there is acrimony between Fritzler and Jack as both men accused the other of interrupting him.

Several people got up to defend the CCTVB, includingformer mayoral candidate Sam Goldman, CCTVB Board chair Trace Brown (and owner of the Holiday Inn), and the manager of the Super 8, as well as a student in the SIUC Hospitality program, who spent much of his time behind the podium attacking Mayor Fritzler for stating on his official biography that his only goal as mayor was to help SIUC (it's not, you can read the whole thing here), then wanting to strip money away from CCTVB which would harm the Hospitality Management program at SIUC, and the organizer of a Marine reunion in Carbondale last year, who said the CCTVB had been quite helpful in organizing their reunion last year.

A couple of people, including me, got up to say that the CCTVB had not been particularly helpful in putting gone events in Carbondale (I have helped put on annual gaming conventions since the early 90s in Carbondale and have gotten little if any help over the years from the CCTVB, so am likely viewing the CCTVB with a jaundiced eye).  Had to leave soon after that, so am not sure what time the meeting wrapped up.